Sunday, July 29, 2007
Ben Hardaway -- the Birth of the Screwball
At the Golden Age Cartoons forum, Lonesome-Lenny shares his theory about Ben Hardaway:
It seems pretty clear to me that he is the creator of the "daffy" screwball character, as we know it, in classic Hollywood cartoons. He had a strong hand in creating Bugs Bunny, and it's evident that he played an equally strong role in creating Woody Woodpecker. I'm uncertain if he contributed to any of Daffy Duck's early appearances, but I'd guess it's likely he did. Hardaway was truly onto something with this notion of the anti-social, screwball character. It was a fresh wind of influence in animation. It helped others give up trying to create an imitation Mickey Mouse, and fanned the flames of the brash, lively spirit of 1940s animation.
J. J. Hunsecker disagrees with this theory (and doesn't seem to be a very big fan of Hardaway's cartoons, either):
I wouldn't credit Hardaway with the creation of the "daffy" screwball character. I give that credit to Tex Avery, with Porky's Duck Hunt (the writing is credited to Rich Hogan for that cartoon. Though sometimes the credits on the Schlesinger cartoons are wrong). From the interviews I've read it seems that Hardaway decided to imitate Porky's Duck Hunt with Porky's Hare Hunt, by putting Daffy in a rabbit suit. The "daffy" hare eventually evolved into Bugs Bunny thanks again to Tex Avery. Woody Woodpecker is also based on Avery's version of Daffy Duck.
Hardaway's entire style -- from writing, drawing, and directing -- was crude and unsophisticated. Avery might not have been a great draftsman himself, but he was a terrific gagman and director. Shamus Culhane wrote that to Hardaway a joke was a joke, and it didn't matter if it fit the character or not.
Lonesome-Lenny responds:
I do agree that Avery deserves the credit for the basic creation and refinement of the screwball character in animation. Hardaway had his own formula, which he tried out at WB, in competition with Avery's (and Clampett's) and ran amok with at Lantz. What fascinates me is that Hardaway kept pursuing his heavy-handed path, while other writers and directors continued to refine the zany character in animated cartoons.
I re-read portions of Culhane's memoirs last night, and refreshed my memory of how much the director disliked Hardaway's writing. So did co-storyman Milt Schaffer. Culhane describes story meetings in which Hardaway kills himself with his lengthy puns, while Schaffer just rolls his eyes toward the ceiling... I really wonder how Hardaway was able to have such influence in the animation world when his work was so checkered. Perhaps Lantz liked him personally, and wanted to give him steady work?
Sogturtle replies:
Actually Hardaway's cartoon career goes all the way back to Iwerks' Flip the Frog cartoons and we can credit him with a lot (if not all) of the lovably strange and weird humor in those cartoons. His hiring and influence at Schlesinger's is definitely attributable to Friz Freleng. Ben's gag-influence during his six plus years at Schlesinger's really only became recognizable when he graduated up to director and particularly the second time around. Honestly his writing there (or story-editing) is SO submerged into the "omelettes" that the directors and two story crews created that a person can't really detect a clear "Hardaway cartoon mindset" until he took the director's chair.
Whether Ben had any contribution into "Porky's Duck Hunt" is and will remain unknown since the story-crews alternated and the cartoon bears no story credit. As such we really can only credit Tex Avery with Daffy's creation (and Tex always sat in with the story crew so regardless which crew helped with the cartoon, the demented duck had to have been Tex's baby). HOWEVER as well documented, Hardaway loved the idea of Daffy being a looney-tooney character and latched onto it with the oft quoted line "I'm going to put that duck into a rabbit suit". And THAT is where Ben's weakness is most obvious as he and the crews came up with some fine and funny gags in his and Dalton's two rabbit cartoons, but he showed NO understanding of HOW to create a LIKABLE character. His rabbit is not just looney but patently obnoxious in those cartoons.
Labels:
Ben Hardaway,
Bugs Bunny,
Daffy Duck,
Looney Tunes,
Woody Woodpecker
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
56 comments:
I agree, Hardaway did have a strong hand in creating the character. He offered more than just his nickname, however, his drawing suggested the personality that developed. That's why the posessive apostrophe(Bugs' Bunny) has been part of the story from the beginning. The drawing can be seen here, http://bugshardaway.blogspot.com/
"No ability to create a likable character" ???
Bugs Bunny and Woody Woodpecker aren't enough to prove that Hardaway had some ability with character design? The greatest animated character of all time not likable? Wow, tough crowd. There is a very short list of people who have contibuted more to the Golden Age of Animation than Hardaway. Crude and unsophisticated? Perhaps, but certainly not without immense talent and a very high level of skill. The artwork linked here http://bugshardaway.blogspot.com/ does not appear to me to be crude, but rather, very highly skilled. Have you any images to offer of Hardaway's drawing that would substantiate your opinion? Please share.
buy viagra online uk cheap herbal viagra order viagra online splitting viagra viva viagra song cheap cheap viagra viagra facts viagra from canada buy viagra in canada generic soft tab viagra viagra women fda on viagra herbal viagra pfizer viagra
It is very interesting for me to read this post. Thanks for it. I like such topics and anything that is connected to them. I would like to read more on that blog soon.
Nice story you got here. It would be great to read a bit more concerning that topic.
BTW check the design I've made myself Young escort
Your blog keeps getting better and better! Your older articles are not as good as newer ones you have a lot more creativity and originality now keep it up!
I know you geeksve been sharing this apartment for weeks I knowall three of you know where Gingers got Gladys Barrett. John simply would not stop.
amazing animal sex stories
free hot incest stories
mature lesbian hardcore stories
gay sex stories
child spanking stories
I know you geeksve been sharing this apartment for weeks I knowall three of you know where Gingers got Gladys Barrett. John simply would not stop.
This case is constantly bothering me. If anyone is capable of answering this question, then I would be very grateful :) Then what do you think ? How many liters of blood does a adult have? Thanks for constructive answer :)
__________________
[url=http://tusumas.mx/foro/viewtopic.php?f=4&t=99138]xrumer backlinks[/url]
buy xanax bars online generic xanax orange pill - street value of xanax 2mg bars
buy xanax without prescriptions tranxene vs xanax side effects - difference xanax xanax bars
[url=http://dcxvssh.com]IvuMAYASHYSJ[/url] - erJAMSV , http://hhmgziigpu.com
viagra online without prescription safe viagra online orders - buy generic viagra online free shipping
viagra sildenafil viagra long term side effects - buy viagra in las vegas
viagra online without prescription cheap viagra us next day - best way purchase viagra
buy soma soma 350 mg high - buy soma online no prescription mastercard
buy soma online soma online pharmacy - soma pharmacy no prescription
buy soma soma muscle relaxer usa - buy soma magazine
buy soma buy soma hair products toronto - soma pills sleep
buy soma soma 350 mg vs flexeril - soma muscle relaxer erowid
Hi, buy zyban - cheap zyban http://www.wellbutrinonlinesale.net/#cheap-zyban , [url=http://www.wellbutrinonlinesale.net/#generic-zyban ]generic zyban [/url]
Hi, zyban bupropion - bupropion online http://www.wellbutrinonlinesale.net/#bupropion-online , [url=http://www.wellbutrinonlinesale.net/#buy-bupropion ]buy bupropion [/url]
Duke Maternal Fetal Medicine cipro for sale - ciprofloxacin for sale http://www.cheapcipromed.net/#ciprofloxacin-for-sale , [url=http://www.cheapcipromed.net/#cipro-cost ]cipro cost [/url]
Gastritis Medicine generic ciprofloxacin - buy cipro without prescription http://www.cheapcipromed.net/#buy-cipro-without-prescription , [url=http://www.cheapcipromed.net/#purchase-ciprofloxacin-online ]purchase ciprofloxacin online [/url]
Glacier Park Medicine Cabinets finasteride online pharmacy - cost of propecia http://www.propeciahowtosave.net/#cost-of-propecia , [url=http://www.propeciahowtosave.net/#buy-propecia-no-prescription ]buy propecia no prescription [/url]
Sarna Itch Medicine cipro online no prescription - order cipro http://www.cheapcipromed.net/#order-cipro , [url=http://www.cheapcipromed.net/#cipro-online ]cipro online [/url]
Seminole County Illegal Drugs ciprofloxacin cost - cipro without prescription http://www.cheapcipromed.net/#cipro-without-prescription , [url=http://www.cheapcipromed.net/#buy-ciprofloxacin-online ]buy ciprofloxacin online [/url]
tramadol 50mg tramadol overdose 200mg - can tramadol withdrawal kill you
tramadol 50mg buy cheap tramadol overnight - tramadol toothache
order cialis online cialis once day reviews - cialis online in nz
tmd atorvastatin cost - generic lipitor price http://www.lipitordiscountonline.net/#lipitor-online, [url=http://www.lipitordiscountonline.net/#lipitor-online]lipitor for sale [/url]
xrh order atomoxetine - atomoxetine cost http://www.stratteraforsale.net/#atomoxetine-cost , [url=http://www.stratteraforsale.net/#atomoxetine-without-prescription ]atomoxetine without prescription [/url]
xanax online xanax high blood pressure meds - xanax extended release side effects
generic xanax xanax online pharmacy - xanax xr buy online
Hello, maxalt cost - maxalt for sale http://www.maxaltforsale.com/#maxalt-for-sale , [url=http://www.maxaltforsale.com/#maxalt-no-prescription ]maxalt no prescription [/url]
generic xanax xanax dosage dental - s 90 3 xanax bars
generic xanax 1mg xanax effects - effects of .75 mg xanax
buy tramadol tramadol hcl vs norco - buy tramadol online nz
3 cymbalta online - cymbalta online no prescription http://www.cymbaltaonlinerx.net/#cymbalta-online, [url=http://www.cymbaltaonlinerx.net/#cymbalta-online]cymbalta online[/url]
xanax online 2mg klonopin 2mg xanax - xanax 2mg dose
tadalafil online buy cialis online using paypal - generic cialis goedkoop
buy cialis online cialis with dapoxetine reviews - price for cialis daily use
buy cialis online is it safe to buy cialis online usa - buy cialis online with american express
3, generic klonopin online - order klonopin online http://www.klonopinsaleonline.com/#klonopin-for-sale, [url=http://www.klonopinsaleonline.com/#generic-klonopin-online]buy cheap klonopin[/url]
learn how to buy tramdadol tramadol dosage for 20 lb. dog - buy tramadol online from usa
20000 :) Generic Gabapentin - gabapentin without rx http://www.neurontinonlinecheap.net/#Cheap-Gabapentin, [url=http://www.neurontinonlinecheap.net/#Cheap-Gabapentin]Generic Gabapentin[/url]
07 generic prednisolone - order prednisone http://www.prednisoneonlinerx.net/index.html, [url=http://www.prednisoneonlinerx.net/index.html]order prednisone online [/url]
http://www.integrativeonc.org/adminsio/buyklonopinonline/#9183 klonopin side effects and withdrawal - suboxone 8mg 2mg klonopin
http://buytramadolonlinecool.com/#73892 tramadol 100 mg street value - tramadol hcl 37.5
clonazepam drug 2mg klonopin beer - klonopin withdrawal valium
http://www.integrativeonc.org/adminsio/buyklonopinonline/#1735 buy klonopin online canada - klonopin side effects nausea
carisoprodol 350 mg do drug tests test carisoprodol - order carisoprodol no prescription
buy carisoprodol online carisoprodol 350 mg narcotic - carisoprodol 350 mg sleep
12, [url=http://www.nemedicalmassage.com/] Sibutramine Diet Pill [/url] - Cheap Sibutramine - sibutramine without prescription http://www.nemedicalmassage.com/ .
Тhe ωrіte-up hаs proνen necesѕaгу to us.
It’ѕ rеаlly useful аnd yοu're simply obviously quite educated in this field. You get opened up my eyes for you to numerous opinion of this particular subject matter using intriguing and sound articles.
My blog post Meridia
Also visit my weblog : phentermine
Your artіcle offers vегifieԁ helpful to us.
It’s really educational and уou're naturally very educated of this type. You possess popped my face in order to varying thoughts about this kind of subject matter using interesting and reliable written content.
Visit my web blog - cincoelementos.es
Your own post proѵides ρroven necessary tо me.
It’ѕ еxtrеmеly educational and you rеally
are clearlу quite educateԁ of this tуpe.
You get еxposed my peгsonаl sight to numerous
thoughts about thiѕ subject along with intriguing and sound written соntent.
My web blog; buy tramadol online
Post a Comment